It seems to me that true critical thinking means sorting out the good AND the bad and treating them as they deserve.
Sometimes the bad is so prominent that the good isn’t worth dwelling on. But just as often there are strikingly good qualities to the content under scrutiny that are at least a shame to ignore and possibly harmful.
The other side of the coin is the overwhelmingly good content that some people feel deserves nit picking and warnings. Let people make their own [uncritical] critical judgments. Let the petty warnings slide in the face of overwhelming good so as not to taint the good with them.